Just saw the new Star Trek movie. I didn't know if I'd love it or hate it, but one thing I never expected was for it to shine a light on some emotional issues I'm grappling with right now.
First of all, the movie itself - great new renditions of the characters, lots of action, solid special effects, no plot to speak of, and one big problem I'll get to in a minute.
Second of all, the emotional issues. I lived with my wife for ten years after transition. I found myself drifting farther and farther away from her during those days (due to wanting to explore my new life). I met someone (Teresa), moved out, and then gradually moved farther away geographically - 90 minutes, six hours, and now a two day drive from Northern Oregon
During this time, I had worked really hard to maintain my relationships with her and my kids. At least I thought I had. But my idea of a relationship was to drive down, tell them all about what I was doing lately, then drive back.
Email was the same - sharing all the things that were important to me so they wouldn't feel left out. Now is that stupid or what? You don't show people you care by talking about yourself. You do it by asking about and listening to them.
I see now that each of them, especially my son, was relentlessly reaching out to me - looking for some sign - anything - to indicate that I really loved them, cared for them, cared
about them. But all they got was my endless monolog about myself, dismissal of their overtures, and continued proof that I obviously didn't care about them.
Of course I cared about them more than my own life. But is that really true? Would I have gone into transition and robbed them of their father and of a normal life and a parent they didn't have to explain to friends and romantic interests? Would I have left and moved in with someone else? Would I have moved farther and father away? And would I have rebuffed with disinterest all their attempts to share their interests with me.
Hey, I'm a larger than life character. I live a big life. At least I like to think of myself that way. But how many public figures far more successful and famous than my meager status have been prominent and yet horrible parents. Beloved by the public but disappointing to the point of causing pain at home?
But you know, even twenty years after transition I hadn't seen it. It just never occurred to me. I was STILL so self-justified from the days when I got through transition by justifying it in my own mind as a moral imperative.
You probably iknow what I'm talking about. If you are in or went through transition, you have to muster your resolve. You have to risk family, friends, career et al. And the only way you can do this is to basically say, "I was born this way - didn't have a choice - therefore I don't have a choice now, and so I'll do this thing, regardless of the cost, and then do the best for everyone that I can afterwards.
For those of us who are long-time post-ops that's the quality that most bothers us about newbies. Those just starting out are so self-justified they literally CAN'T SEE how much IRREPARABLE damage they are doing to those around them, and how SELFISH they have become.
They see themselves as soldiers of human rights, starting in their own back yard - martyrs in the cause of being true to yourself. And these evangelists (because it suits their current purposes) trod all over everybody else's feelings, unawares, oblivious.
What about real sacrifice - those who work all their lives at jobs they hate to support their children - those who put their loved ones first, not saying "I put them first after this one thing which comes before them."
Truth is, you go into transition you ruin lives. Most will recover and build something frome the rubble - some won't.
But the damndest part is that as long-time post-ops, our attitude about newbies is the very same self-justified attitude we are complaining about in them. We self-justify by saying, "We've been there, done that, see a higher truth, and therefore can pass judgment about those newbies and their selfish doings." We see it as our duty to grab them by their frilly lapels and force them to see the pain they are causing. And all the while we still aren't seeing what's best for others. We've forgotten how close to suicide we all were, how much at the edge of mental illness, drug abuse, or all of the above. We sit in our self-satisfied new lives, decades after all the pathos and expect these poor souls to just step out of their problems and see the big picture. In other words, we're still telling them about us and aren't paying any attention to them.
I think I had that attitude before I started transition. I think I felt so crappy about my own self-worth that I had to be the center of attention to keep proving to myself I could be. I think in one way or another everyone who successfully transitions must have been the kindest, gentlest ass-hole in the world before they even started.
You got gender identity problems? Then you're an ass-hole. Can't help it. The kind of negative self-worth issues transgenderism causes will turn you into one before you are out of your teens. Not to infer that all ass-holes are transgendered, mind you. There's plenty of causes of that malady, but I'm only concerned with this one (because its all about me, isn't it?)
So having developed this trait of justifying myself, I relied on it to get through transition, move away from my family and keep the focus on myself, all the time feeling I was a god for how much I strived to keep in contact with my kids.
Bullshit.
How the hell did they ever manage to stay connected to me all these years? Well, they haven't now. I've pretty much lost my son - not to hatred (though for all I know there's some of that) but to dis-interest. My daughter used to call me every day. Then once a week. Then we'd email every day. Then a couple times a week.
How often did I call her? Almost never. And why? Because in order to feel that I was loved (self-worth issue) calling her wouldn't prove anything. But if she called ME, well then, she loved me! So to insure she would call (because she missed me) I didn't call her, thereby creating a vacuum that would draw her to me. Or at least that must be pretty clear to what my heart was thinking, even though such concepts, while familiar, were always just outside the conscious realm so I had plausible deniabitlity.
My son used to call me all the time and ask me to play video games over the internet with him. I had the game, but I just wasn't into that so I declined. He used to ask questions about guns because he liked the concept of target shooting. Wasn't my cup of tea so I deferred him to Teresa who has experience with firearms.
In short, I kept trying to get him interested in hiking and photography and writing and all the things that matter to me, even while slapping his offered hand away in the things in which he was interested.
And now, it's "Cat's in the Cradle" time. I loved that song as a young man, vowed never to let that happen to me. Yet here we are. That's how it works.
So - what does this have to do with Star Trek? Here the BIG problem I told you I'd talk about....
It's a time travel story. Because of the events that occur, history is changed for Kirk, Spock, Bones, Scotty, et al. In other words, all that happened in the original TV series, the Next Generation, and all the movies is erased as part of the plot of the new movie.
They didn't just say to the audience, "We're re-telling the legend and there will be many changes in our rendition." They said that and THEN said, "And by the way, all those wonderful emotinoal moments and all the characters you came to love like family never existed. Those stories never happened and never will happen."
Well isn't THAT a slap in the face. I don't care about being true to the way the story was told before. But I take all kinds of exception to all that being wiped away.
But, and here's the connection, isn't that my situation today? The future I might have had with my kids - the ball games, the birthday parties, the little day to day experiences that draw people together - all of it was erased by my self-justified transition, leaving the family, and moving away. I killed that future as surely as Star Trek killed the past.
I've always kept the belief that I'd "make it all up to them someday". I remember first having that thought one Christmas when I gave my parents (who had no money for a new couch) a picture of a sofa with a note saying I was going to make one for them. Never happened.
And I kept thinking that someday I'd make enough money so my mom could retire in comfort. She died in 1989.
In fact, just about any grandiose promise I've ever made I've failed to deliver (except of course to myself, as evidenced by the person I've become).
There is now making up for it later. And I've come to realize that. So, I figured if I can't make up for it, then at least I can keep promises from this point forward. But how can I get everybody back in my corner? How can I show them I have enough value to make it worth their while to give me another chance? (Note self-worth still sitting in the middle of this?)
I thought I'd begin by reminding them of all the great times we had as a family before transition began. I'd haul out the old videos and convert them to DVD and give copies to each of them (did this two years ago). Then I'd scan the best of the old family photos of our many vacations and special events from when the kids were little and turn them into an album I could present to the whole family with a CD copy for everyone, including a few pix of me now doing things with them to create the bridge I needed. (Did this last Christmas).
And lately I created a blog for the family pictures and videos I had not yet shown them so I could give them an ongoing experience of family as they checked in with all my frequent updates and new postings (Started that last week and was working on it just before I started writing this post).
But you see, just like Star Trek, I not only charted a coure to an alternate future, but I had always erased the past. How? The moment I revealed my decision to change sex, all their memories of who I was and what I was all about changed in that very instant. Everything they thought and felt about their family and their place in it and their relationships not just with me but with each other and all the other people we knew - all that changed into a new reality, retroactively, just as surely if some stupid time travel gag had re-written the past.
So all the harping I've done for the last couple of years about the past is trying to sell them on a history that just isn't there anymore. I'm trying to say, 'remember how you felt about this?" but they can't, because history has been changed and those things never happened.
Sure, they can recall the events, but the feelings are no longer there. They've been altered. Psychologists will tell you about retrograde changes that occur in old memories every time new information is added. Have any of us not re-evaluated someone based on new information? Have we not heard the phrase in the movies, "I thought you were my friend" when someone learns someone they trusted turned out to be working against them. Suddenly all the feelings they had of happiness or security are replaced with feelings of betrayal instead.
Note that betrayal isn't added onto the old fond memories - it replaces them. At that moment, the old feelings cease to exist and they are never coming back.
What a fool I've been to keep slapping the whole family with all these old momentos. Since they no longer mean anything to anyone but me, constantly drawing their attention to them is just perpetuating my life-long habit of putting the focus on me. It looks to them as if I just want to talk about those now, rather than what is current in their lives, which I still don't acknowledge since I am so desparate to reconnect I don't have time to come up for air from my own tunnel vision effort to force them to remember the past as "I" see it and then connect those feelings to me today.
All about me again.
Here's the rub. Now that I finally realize this, is there any way to correct it from 1,000 miles away? Those original family feelings were made not in an instant, but like snowfall building slowly into drifts. Every little question, every meal, every television program watched together created them. And transition washed them all away.
Now I'm 1/24th they way around the globe from them and all I have is phone and email. Since there is no past I need to build a new relationship with each of them and with all of them together as a family. But my daughter is married and away from home for five years. My son is thirty and has made good friends with the next door older neighbor who show him how to build things and takes him fishing. And Mary, my wife, has learned to be completely self-sufficient.
Even if it were possible to build new relationships with them, would THEY want to be any closer to me than the distance I've pushed them away? In other words, if we met for the first time today, being the people we have all become, would we have any reason to get to know each other? What's more, how many people you meet for the first time who live two days away have become your close friends?
I suppose Twitter and Facebook and email can make new friends and grow them closer, but you know, I'm 56 and I'm not sure that works for me. (Me again, see? Gotta be on my terms. I want them all to be closer, but only in the way I choose).
Clearly this attitude has got to change. But even if it does, what can I do? I have to believe there's still some sort of connection amongst us all. Perhaps the past was altered but not really erased, just an alternate reality that still has some touch points, some aspects of significance to us all.
I love it where I've moved. I love who I'm living with. I love the person I've become. But I love them all too. My task now is to listen like a SETI station for that faint voice from across the void. To tune in and connect and find common ground for communication. And, if possible with such an astronomical distance between us, build a relationship from this day forward, based on who we have all become in this parallel universe.